Best Overall
Salomon XA Pro 3D
Key details
- Fit
- Can run large
- Closure
- Quick-pull cord
- Stability
- Stable on trail
- Arch Support
- Supportive
The Salomon XA Pro 3D is the pair we hand to a friend who wants one shoe for a hiking trip. The quick-pull lacing is the first thing we noticed: one tug snugs the whole upper, and there are no loose loops to catch on brush or dangle in mud. Underfoot, the shoe feels planted on uneven ground, and the arch support is substantial enough that we did not think about our feet on long descents. It has the low, flexible shape of a trail runner rather than the stiff, high-cut feel of a hiking boot, which is exactly what we want for a day pack.
On mixed dirt, gravel, and rock, the outsole gave us confident footing. We liked the lacing most on steep sections, where we could tighten the shoe without stopping to retie. The upper holds the midfoot securely, and the ride stays steady when the trail turns loose or off-camber. We also appreciated that it works beyond hiking: it is a credible gym and everyday shoe, which makes it easier to justify the premium.
What keeps this from being a pure hiking boot is also what makes it useful: it is light enough to move quickly, but it does not coddle your feet. If you want pillow-soft cushioning, this is not the shoe. We came back to it because it makes rough ground feel more predictable, and that is the quality we value most on a hike.
Pros
- Quick-pull lacing adjusts on the move
- Stable, supportive ride on uneven trails
- Works for hiking, trail running, and gym use
Cons
- Fit can run large and narrow
Our best overall pick for hikers who want a stable, protective trail runner with quick lacing and enough support for long days.