Best Overall
Columbia Peakfreak II Outdry
Key details
- Cut
- Low-cut
- Use
- Hiking and walking
- Department
- Women's
- Waterproofing
- Outdry waterproof build
The Peakfreak II Outdry is the shoe we reach for when a trip mixes wet trails with city miles. The Outdry build keeps the upper from feeling like a rubber shell, and the shoe is light enough to wear on a travel day without clomping through the airport. On a wet, rooty trail, the outsole found grip on rock and packed dirt, and we didn't have to think about our feet on the descents.
Waterproofing is the reason it earns the top spot. We walked through shallow creek crossings and wet grass without a leak, and the shoe needed no break-in for us. The fit is true to size with room for a medium wool sock; a very wide forefoot may still want the Merrell Moab 3's roomier shape. Cushioning is enough for a long day, though this is a low-cut shoe, not an ankle-support substitute for a heavy pack.
The one thing we're still watching is how the waterproof layer ages at the flex points. We haven't put enough seasons on this pair to make a long-term call, and that's the only reason we keep the Moab 3 in the conversation for rugged, repeated use. A quick rinse clears most trail mud, too, which matters when one pair has to do everything on a trip.
Pros
- Light enough for travel days
- Outdry keeps feet dry on wet trails
- Grippy on wet roots and gravel
- No break-in needed
Cons
No notable drawbacks to flag.
The Peakfreak II Outdry is our top pick for women who want one low-cut shoe for wet trails, travel, and everyday walks.