Best Overall
Columbia Peakfreak II Outdry
Key details
- Type
- Low-cut trail shoe
- Model
- 2005101
- Waterproofing
- Outdry
A waterproof trail shoe shouldn't feel like a compromise, and this one doesn't. The Peakfreak II is one of the two lightest-feeling shoes in this group that still has a real outsole under it, and after a few wet mornings it became the pair we stopped thinking about: no hot spots, no sloshing, no hunting for the edge of every rock. Most shoes here are good at one of light, dry or grippy. This one is good at all three, which is why it is our top pick.
Outdry bonds the waterproof layer to the outside of the upper rather than hiding it behind a lining, and you can feel the difference, because the shoe flexes like a trainer instead of a sealed boot. Rain, wet grass and shallow puddles are its territory. A stream crossing is not: no low-cut shoe keeps out water that comes over the collar, and we don't hold that against it. What we did watch for was heat, since a dry foot that has steamed for six miles is no win, and this one runs cooler than the rubber-heavy hikers here.
Traction is the pleasant surprise. The lugs are shallow enough that pavement doesn't feel like walking on toy bricks, but they are shaped to bite, and on wet roots and greasy rock we never had the half-second slip that makes you shorten your stride for the rest of the day. Fit is true to size with a genuinely roomy forefoot, which surprised us given how low-volume the shoe looks on the shelf, and our toes stayed spread on descents instead of jamming into the front.
What to keep an eye on is the sole-to-upper bond, the place light hiking shoes tend to give up first. Flex the pair in your hands when they arrive and glance at the join every month or so; if it starts lifting at the toe, you want to know before a trip rather than during one. Buy them for day-length three-season hiking and they will do everything you ask.
Pros
- Running-shoe weight with real trail grip
- Outdry keeps water out without a clammy feel
- Roomy toe box despite the low-volume look
Cons
- Sole bond is the first thing to fail
The pair we point most hikers to: a running shoe's weight and flex on wet trails, with Outdry waterproofing that doesn't leave your feet stewing.