Best Overall
Merrell Moab 2 Vent
Key details
- Upper
- Ventilated
- Widths
- Standard and wide
- Insoles
- Removable
Start with the Moab 2 Vent if you want a hiking shoe you do not have to think about. It is the low-cut, ventilated member of Merrell's long-running Moab family, and it is the pair we reached for most often when a day mixed dirt road, rocky singletrack, and a long hot climb. It felt worn in from the first lace-up, with no stiff collar and no rubbing at the ankle.
Fit is a large part of why it takes the top spot. The shoe runs true to size, and the line includes wide widths, which is the fix when your usual size pinches across the toes. The toe box is the one place to be deliberate: a wider forefoot can feel the edges of it, so try the wide before deciding the model is not for you. The footbed lifts out, so an orthotic or a thicker insole drops straight in.
On the trail this is the supportive end of lightweight. There is enough structure to stop your foot rolling on loose rock, and the arch support is real rather than decorative, the kind you notice most on a long descent. It is not the lightest shoe here; the Siren Edge 3 is the one to look at if low weight is the priority. What the Moab buys with that extra substance is a planted, steady feel and a shoe that still feels supportive at hour six.
The ventilated upper is why we kept choosing these for hot, dry days: it breathes, and after a stream crossing it dries faster than a waterproof shoe will. If your trips are mostly damp and shoulder-season, the KEEN Targhee 3 Low further down is the better answer. For the money, nothing else here covers as much ground.
Pros
- Comfortable from the first mile, no break-in
- Ventilated upper breathes and dries fast
- Supportive arch and stable on rough trail
- Wide widths and a removable footbed
Cons
- Ventilated upper is not waterproof
We tell most women to start here: it is the most complete light hiker in this group, comfortable from the first mile and steady on rough ground.