Best Overall
Merrell Moab 3
Key details
- Outsole
- Vibram tread
- Toe Box
- Roomy
- Wide Widths
- Available
Merrell builds the Moab 3 in a wide width, and the front of the shoe is generous even in the standard fit, two things that matter more than any number printed on a size chart. Toes lie flat instead of curling under their neighbors, and the heel still locks down, which is what wide sizing usually gives up.
Comfort is why it's our top pick. The padding around the collar and tongue is soft enough that a full first day didn't leave the hot spots we were braced for, and the shoe flexes at the ball of the foot instead of fighting every step. The Vibram outsole handles the rest: it bit into wet rock and loose gravel on descents where we expected a slide.
This is a trail shoe first and a sneaker second, and it looks it, with a chunky sole and a workmanlike upper that makes no claim to being sleek. What keeps it at the top is range. It's the pair we reach for on a day hike, a muddy dog walk, or a travel day when one shoe has to cover everything.
Pros
- A real wide width, not just extra volume
- Heel stays locked down despite the room
- Vibram outsole grips wet rock and gravel
- Walkable from the first day
Cons
- Toe bumper and sole edge can peel with hard use
For most wide-footed hikers we tested with, the Moab 3 is the pair to buy: a real wide width, a roomy toe box, and grip that holds on wet rock.