Best Overall
Merrell Moab 3 Mid Waterproof
Key details
- Ankle Height
- Mid
- Waterproofing
- Waterproof
- Listed Package Weight
- 11.7 oz
The Moab 3 Mid is the boot we recommend first because it gets the unglamorous parts right: it cushions a long day, holds the ankle without feeling like a cast, and leaves enough room in the toe box that the descent does not turn into a countdown. In this group, it is the most complete trail boot, and its durability is stronger than most of the others here. We also like that it feels broken in early, without the hot spots that send people back to the car.
The waterproof membrane is the part to buy with eyes open. It handles rain, mud, and shallow puddles, but wet grass and sustained wet conditions can get through; treat it as weather protection, not a wading boot. The fit is roomy through the forefoot, which is why it works for men who usually struggle with narrow hikers. The ankle collar holds without pressure across the front of the shin.
Where it beat the others for us was versatility. It is light enough for day hikes, stable enough for a loaded pack, and simple enough to wear into town afterward. If your trails are mostly wet grass and boggy ground, look at the Newton Ridge; for everything else, start here.
Pros
- Cushioned enough for long days
- Roomy toe box with a stable heel
- Durability stronger than most here
- Easy break-in
Cons
- Runs small for some feet
For most men who want one trail boot for day hikes and the occasional loaded pack, the Moab 3 is the best all-around choice here.