Best Overall
Gear Doctors Oxylus
Key details
- Weight
- 2.2 lb
- R-Value
- 4.3
- Inflation
- Self-inflating, no pump
- Inflated Size
- 72 x 22 x 1.5 in
An R-value of 4.3 on a pad that weighs 2.2 pounds is the whole argument for it. Warmth and weight are the two things that usually force a trade in this category, since the warm foam-and-air pads get heavy and the ultralight inflatables leave you guessing about insulation, and this is the one pad here that refuses the trade. That's why it tops the list.
In camp it behaves the way a self-inflating pad should: unroll it, open the valve, and the foam does most of the work while you're staking out the tent. The core is 1.5 inches, the thinnest of the self-inflating pads here, which makes for a firm night rather than a plush one, and a firm flat surface is exactly what stops a hip from rolling into a hollow at 3 a.m.
Value is the other half of the case. It sits in the middle of this set on price, below the Coleman and well below the Teton, and it's the only one at that money giving you genuine insulation without four pounds on your back. A repair patch comes in the box, which is the kind of small thing that suggests the maker expects it to be used.
Two point two pounds is a weekend-trip weight rather than a thru-hike one. If you're counting ounces for a long trail, the Z Lite Sol below is the better answer. For everything short of that, a basecamp, a weekend loop, a car trip with a mile of walking at the end, it's the pad that makes the fewest demands.
Pros
- R-4.3 warmth at just 2.2 pounds
- Self-inflates without a pump or a lungful
- Firm flat surface that suits side sleepers
- Mid-set price for shoulder-season warmth
Cons
- Needs a few extra breaths to firm up fully
Our default for most campers: 4.3 R-value warmth at 2.2 pounds, comfortable enough for side sleepers, and simple enough to set up in the dark.