Best Overall
Columbia Watertight II
Key details
- Fit
- Runs large
- Weight
- Lightweight
- Packability
- Packs into a daypack
- Water Resistance
- Waterproof
A hiking rain shell should disappear into your pack until the weather turns, then do its job without fuss. The Columbia Watertight II is the one we reach for first. It is light enough to forget in a daypack, packs down small, and has kept us dry through steady rain on exposed walks. The hood sits close around the face, and the front zip seals out drips without feeling stiff.
The jacket has a clean, uncluttered cut for hiking: no extra fabric flapping around your arms, and the shell moves with you on a climb. The zippered hand pockets keep a phone and keys secure, and the front zip seals out drips without feeling stiff. It is not a warm jacket on its own, so treat it as the outer layer and add insulation when the temperature drops.
The North Face Antora is the roomier alternative if you want more space for layers and bigger pockets. The Columbia is the better everyday hiking shell for most people because it is lighter and easier to pack, and it costs less than the premium picks here. If you want one rain jacket for three-season day hikes, start here.
Pros
- Light and packable
- Reliably dry in steady rain
- Secure zippered pockets
- Simple hood and trail-friendly cut
Cons
- Runs large; size down for a close fit
We recommend the Watertight II as the best all-around hiking shell here: it is light, packable, and reliably dry in steady rain, with a simple cut that suits most three-season hikes.