Best Overall
Columbia Newton Ridge Plus Waterproof Amped
Key details
- Style
- Women's hiking boot
- First Listed
- 2020
- Waterproofing
- Waterproof
The Newton Ridge is the boot we recommend first, and it comes down to water. Of the four pairs here, this is the one with the least to answer for when the weather turns: rain, wet grass, mud and shallow crossings stay outside, and the boot keeps its finish instead of soaking through and staining. There's a limit worth knowing — water can find its way in where the leather meets the tongue once a crossing gets deep — but a clear boundary you can plan around beats a vague waterproof promise.
Comfort is what keeps it at the top. The forefoot is roomy enough for a wide foot or a thick sock, the heel stays put instead of sliding, and the ankle collar supports without pressing anywhere. It isn't plush from day one: the leather and the laces need a few miles to soften, and the first couple of hikes are where you feel that.
What we didn't expect to like so much is how well it works once you're off the trail. It reads as a hiking boot but walks like a sneaker, so it's the pair that stays on for the walk into town afterward. Arch support here is real rather than nominal, the sole is stiff enough for rocky ground, and if you're only buying one pair of boots for a season of trips, this is the one to try first.
Pros
- Best water-resistance record in this set
- Roomy forefoot that still holds the heel
- Solid ankle and arch support for a mid-cut boot
- Looks good enough to wear around town
Cons
- Needs a few miles of break-in first
The boot we recommend first for most hikers: the driest, easiest-wearing pair here, with support for a full day and a look that doesn't shout trail.