Best Overall
Earth Pak Waterproof Backpack
Key details
- Closure
- Roll-top
- Capacity
- 55 liters
- Material
- PVC
- Water Resistance
- Waterproof
The roll-top is the whole argument for this pack. You fold the mouth down three or four times, clip the buckle across, and the main compartment is sealed rather than coated: a PVC shell with no zip running through the body of the bag. That puts it in a different class of protection from everything else here, and it is why this is the pack we take when the forecast is genuinely bad.
Fifty-five liters sounds like an expedition, but a roll-top is a variable-volume closure. Fill it two-thirds, roll further down, and the shoulder straps cinch the load into something much closer to a 35-liter daypack. We liked that flexibility for a bag that has to cover a gear-heavy overnighter and a light day hike on the same trip. The padded back panel, contoured straps and low sternum strap carry a day's load comfortably, and the PVC shrugs off brush and grit in a way the thin packable fabrics here do not.
One detail worth knowing before you rely on it: the outside zip pocket is splash-proof, not waterproof. A phone, a paper map or a passport belongs inside the roll, not in that pocket. Do that and the only thing you give up is convenience at the trailhead.
Pros
- Sealed roll-top keeps gear dry in sustained rain
- Compresses from 55 liters to daypack bulk
- Padded back panel, contoured straps and sternum strap
Cons
- Roll-top has to be folded and buckled at every stop
- One main compartment, so small items need stuff sacks
Buy this one if the hike will be wet rather than might be wet: the roll-top seals, the harness is padded, and 55 liters squeezes down to daypack size.