Best Overall
KEEN Newport H2
Key details
- Closure
- Lace with adjustable slider
- Water Use
- Designed for water
- Department
- Men's
- Toe Coverage
- Closed toe
A closed toe is the whole argument for this one. On rocky ground you stop scanning every step, because roots and stones hit the front of the sandal instead of your toenails. None of the open picks here can do that, and on a trip that mixes gravel paths with a stream crossing it's the detail we appreciate most. The upper drains rather than filling up, and the footbed is quick to dry once you're out of the water.
What makes it the pick rather than just a sturdy shell is the support underneath. The arch is pronounced enough to carry a long walking day, and the fit stays secure once the sandal is soaked, which is the part that matters when a trail turns into a creek. It also manages to look purposeful rather than clinical, so it doesn't feel like a piece of gear you have to change out of before dinner.
Getting them on is the part we grumble about. The heel strap has very little give, so a high instep means loosening the lace first, then pulling the heel into place with a thumb. Do that before you step into the water, not while standing in it. Otherwise the fit is straightforward: heel seated at the back, toe strap snug, and the lacing adjusted once rather than fiddled with all day.
Pros
- Closed toe takes rock and root strikes
- Real arch support for long walking days
- Drains and dries after a soaking
Cons
- Stitching and seams can give out early
For rocky trails and river crossings, we point readers to the Newport H2: the closed toe takes the knocks and the footbed carries a long day.