Best Overall
WHITIN W20
Key details
- Model
- W20
- Shoe Type
- Minimalist trail running
- Department
- Men's
The low-cost end of this category has a dirty secret: most of those shoes are water shoes with a hiking label, soft rubber with almost no lug. The WHITIN W20 is the exception. It is sold as a trail runner, and that is where the outsole comes from, a real tread pattern that bites into gravel, wet rock, and loose dirt instead of skating over them. On a stony descent, that stops being a specification and starts being the reason you stay upright.
The rest is honest minimalist construction. The sole is thin and very flexible, the heel and forefoot sit level with each other, and there is so little padding that your foot does the work, which is what you came for. It is light, too: we stopped noticing we had them on a few minutes into a walk, and they never became a shoe we had to manage.
Sizing is the trap. They run small and there are no half sizes, so go up one from your usual, and up again if you hike in thick wool socks. The toe box is roomy without being the widest here, with plenty of room for your toes to spread on a descent but less than the toe-pocket models. If maximum splay is the goal, the Vibram pairs below are where to look.
The upper is what ages. Seams and straps can tear while the outsole still has tread left, so plan on a couple of seasons of regular use rather than a decade, and do not expect it to shrug off a soaking. In return you get the tread, the flexibility, and a shape that suits a normal-width foot, at a price that leaves room for a second pair of camp shoes.
Pros
- Real tread that grips loose rock and gravel
- Thin, flexible sole with heel and forefoot level
- Light enough to forget you are wearing it
- Far cheaper than the toe-pocket options
Cons
- Upper seams and straps can tear early
Our default pick for most hikers: the only affordable shoe here whose tread holds on loose rock, over a sole thin and flexible enough to still feel barefoot.