Best Overall
Acme Projects Rain Pants
Key details
- Seams
- Taped
- Department
- Men's
- Listed Weight
- 10.6 oz
- Waterproof Rating
- 10,000mm / 3,000g
Only one pair here puts a number on its waterproofing. The Acme Projects shell lists a 10,000mm rating and a 3,000g breathability figure, and it is the only one with taped seams. Tape seals the stitch holes that otherwise leak at the thigh, and that leak is the failure that ruins an otherwise decent shell. For hiking in steady, three-season rain, it is why this is our top pick.
Weight and cut do the rest of the work. At 10.58 ounces listed, the pair sits in a daypack without announcing itself, and the leg is generous enough to pull over hiking trousers and a light fleece. Size it for those layers rather than for your street size. A shell is meant to go over things, not against skin, and the roominess that looks odd in a mirror is what lets you get it on at a trailhead on a cold morning.
Breathability is the compromise. A 3,000g figure is modest, and on a long climb in full rain gear you will feel warmth building behind the fabric whether or not the rain gets in. That is how shells work rather than a flaw in this one, and it is the trade we take for a pair this light. Wear them when it is raining or blowing, and strip them off before a big ascent if the weather lets you.
What brings us back is simpler than any specification: the pair removes a decision. It goes into the pack at the start of a trip and comes out when the sky turns, with nothing to think about in between.
Pros
- Stated 10,000mm rating with taped seams
- Listed at 10.58 ounces
- Least expensive of these picks
Cons
- Men's cut only
We recommend the Acme Projects pair to most hikers: it is the only shell here with a stated 10,000mm rating and taped seams, and it costs the least.