Best Overall
Columbia Watertight II
Key details
- Fit
- Men's, runs roomy
- Pockets
- Zippered hand pockets
- Packed Size
- Packs small in a daypack
- Waterproofing
- Handles heavy rain
Rain shells live on a trade: the more protection you want, the more jacket you carry. The Watertight II gets that balance best in this group, which is why it's our top pick. We wore it through a long, steady soaking and the layer underneath stayed dry, and by the end of the day it rolled down into something we could push behind a daypack's lid.
Wind is the part people forget. A wet shell that lets wind through makes a cold day colder, and this one blocks it without turning into a sauna — step indoors and it doesn't trap heat the way a coated jacket can. It dries quickly too, so a wet morning doesn't leave you with a damp pack all afternoon.
The cut is the thing to plan around. It runs roomy, which is exactly what you want over a fleece and exactly what you don't want if you're between sizes and hoping for a trim fit, and the sleeves run long. If you're at the boundary, order your normal size and let your layers take up the space.
What earns it the top spot is consistency: this is the shell in this group with the fewest lingering questions about its waterproofing, and the one we point to first when someone asks what to buy before a week of uncertain weather. If you overheat on humid summer climbs, the vented 33,000ft shell further down is the better tool.
Pros
- Keeps heavy rain out
- Light and small in a pack
- Blocks wind without trapping heat
- Dries fast between showers
Cons
- Runs roomy with long sleeves
It keeps heavy rain out, blocks wind, and packs down small — the jacket we recommend to most hikers, provided you want room for a fleece.