Best Overall
Merrell Moab 3 Hiking Shoe
Key details
- Style
- Low-cut hiking shoe
- Dimensions
- 15 x 10 x 5 in
- Listed Weight
- 3.06 lb
A hiking shoe that needs breaking in is a hiking shoe that will blister you on the trip you bought it for. The Moab 3 did not ask for that grace period: our pair went out onto roots and rock without a hot spot, and the forefoot is wide enough that toes have somewhere to go on a long descent. If you hike a few weekends a year and want one pair that also handles the walk to the store, that out-of-the-box comfort is the whole argument.
Where it earns the top spot here is the balance of grip and support. The tread bites on wet rock and loose gravel, the surfaces where a day hike actually gets interesting, and there is enough substance under the arch that a sharp stone does not come straight through to your foot. It is the heaviest of the three at a listed 3.06 pounds, and you feel that on a long climb; what you get back is a shoe that feels planted rather than skittish when the trail tilts.
The front of the shoe is the part to watch. The rubber wrap that covers the toe can peel away from the upper, and the heel padding can flatten and roll with heavy wear, failures that turn up after a hard season rather than a hard weekend. Scramble a lot or kick steps into dirt and that toe bumper is worth a look before each season. Half sizes are available, which counts for more than it sounds like if you usually land between two.
Pros
- Comfortable from the first mile, no break-in
- Wide toe box with a locked-in heel
- Reliable grip on wet rock and gravel
- Strong value for a do-everything shoe
Cons
- Toe bumper can peel away with hard use
For weekend day hikes and everyday wear, this is the pair we tell people to buy first: roomy, grippy, and comfortable straight out of the box.