Best Overall
KEEN Arroyo 2
Key details
- Sizing
- Runs large
- Outsole
- Aggressive lug pattern
- Listed Weight
- 15 oz
- Toe And Heel Coverage
- Closed toe, closed heel
Two sandals here close the toe, and the Arroyo 2 is the one built for the trail rather than the river. A thick rubber bumper takes the hits from roots and scree, the heel is closed instead of strapped, and the outsole carries an aggressive lug pattern. On loose, steep ground with a daypack on, it is the pair we trusted most and the one we stopped thinking about.
Trail duty is the design brief here, not an afterthought. The footbed carries enough arch for a full day on your feet, and the closed heel keeps the sandal from sliding forward on a descent, which is the thing that turns an open sandal into a stubbed toe on a downhill. It is also the pick that got us through a wet, rooty stretch without a single pebble working its way underfoot.
Sizing is where this one gets messy. The fit runs large for some feet and wide for others, so order from somewhere with easy exchanges and get them on your feet well before a long hike rather than at the trailhead. Fifteen ounces on the spec sheet is more than the webbing sandals here, and that weight is the price of the protection.
Pros
- Closed toe and heel keep grit and rocks out
- Aggressive lug pattern grips loose, rocky ground
- Supportive footbed for long days under a pack
Cons
- Most expensive pick in this group
- 15-ounce build is heavier than the webbing picks
The pair we send a hiker to first: closed-toe protection, a lugged sole, and a footbed that holds up under a pack. Budget for a sizing exchange.