Best Overall
The North Face Antora
Key details
- Fit
- Generous for layering
- Pockets
- Large hand pockets
- Wind Protection
- Windproof
- Water Protection
- Waterproof
The North Face Antora is the jacket we reach for when the forecast is mixed and the route climbs. It is a proper waterproof shell, not an insulated jacket, and the cut is generous enough to fit a base layer and a light fleece without pulling across the shoulders. That room matters on a hike: you can swing your arms uphill without the hem fighting you. We were also impressed by how well it blocks wind on exposed sections, and by the huge hand pockets, which swallow gloves and a map.
The fabric breathes well enough for active hiking, and rain stays out in steady weather. It does not add warmth, so on a cold, wet day you will want a fleece or puffy underneath. That is the deal with a shell: it protects you from the weather, then gets out of the way. The Antora does that without much weight, which is why it works as a three-season layer.
The fit is the main thing to get right. The body is roomy by design, and the sleeves run long on shorter frames. If you are between sizes and want a trim layer, size down; if you plan to wear a puffy underneath, stay with your normal size. The room is the point, but it can swamp a lean hiker who never layers.
What settles it for us is the combination of room, windproofing, and a waterproof face that keeps you dry on a long, exposed day. It is the shell we pack when the weather can turn and we need to keep moving, not the jacket we wear for a mild stroll.
Pros
- Roomy enough for a base layer and fleece
- Strong wind and rain protection
- Huge hand pockets
Cons
- Sleeves run long on shorter frames
For wet, windy three-season hikes, this is the roomy waterproof shell we recommend first.