Best Overall
Reliance Aqua-Tainer 7 Gallon
Key details
- Spigot
- Hideaway with screw vent
- Capacity
- 7 gallons
- Material
- Polyethylene
Seven gallons is the number that decides this one. At the gallon-a-person-a-day most of us plan around at camp, that is a couple through a long weekend with enough left to rinse dishes and top off a dog bowl. It is also why we fill it where it sits rather than carrying it: a full Aqua-Tainer is a two-handed lift, and nobody who has lugged one pretends otherwise.
The details around that capacity are why it is our default. A screw-on vent lets air in as water leaves, so the spigot pours a steady stream instead of gulping and splashing down the side of the jug. The spigot tucks into a recess so it is not the first thing to snap off in a truck bed, and the rectangular body stacks when empty, which matters if you keep two or three of them in a garage with no shelves.
Sun is the thing that will shorten its life. Prolonged direct exposure makes polyethylene brittle, and the manufacturer's own warning is blunt about it, so ours lives in the garage between trips and sits in the shade at camp rather than on the sunny side of the picnic table. The molded grip on top helps with the lift, though the sensible habit is to slide the jug to the edge of the tailgate before you open the spigot.
The detail we did not expect to appreciate is the cap. It reverses: one way it covers the spigot for the drive, the other way it is the cap you pull off to pour. Nothing loose to lose in the dark, which at a campsite is a bigger deal than it sounds.
Pros
- Seven gallons covers a group for a long weekend
- Screw vent keeps the flow steady, not gulping
- Spigot cap reverses to protect it in transit
- Stacks and stores flat when empty
Cons
- Rigid walls can crack if knocked around
For group car camping this is the jug we recommend first: seven gallons, a vented spigot that pours cleanly, and a body that stacks flat when the trip is over.