Best Overall
Merrell All Out Blaze
Key details
- Fit
- Runs large
- Type
- Hiking water shoe
- Toe Box
- Wide
- Traction
- Wet and dry
Most water shoes feel like a sock with a sole; the Merrell All Out Blaze Aero Sport is the exception. It's built like a breathable hiking shoe, with a mesh upper that lets water out and air in, and a toe box that gives your toes room without letting them slide. We wore it on wet rock, loose gravel, and dry trail, and it felt like a shoe we could keep hiking in rather than something to change out of at the water's edge.
That combination is why it's our top pick. It has the surest wet-rock grip and the most trail-ready support in this set, so a crossing doesn't turn the rest of the hike into a careful shuffle. The mesh dries fast enough that we didn't feel waterlogged on the walk back, and the build feels more substantial than the thin aqua socks here.
The fit runs large, so size down if you're between sizes, and lace it snugly before a crossing. The roomy toe box is a plus on descents, when toes tend to jam forward; the trade-off is a little more shoe to pack than a roll-up water sock.
What sold us was the way it handled a wet, rocky exit: the sole stayed planted, the upper drained, and we didn't have to think about our feet again until the trail turned dry. If your trips are mostly flat beach walks, it's more shoe than you need.
Pros
- Sure wet-rock grip and dry traction
- Breathable mesh dries quickly
- Roomy toe box and sturdy build
- Comfortable for all-day wear
Cons
- Costs more than other picks here
Buy the Merrell if you want one shoe for the hike and the river; it has the surest wet-rock grip and the most trail-ready support here.