Best Overall
Merrell All Out Blaze
Key details
- Closure
- Lace-up
- Drainage
- Channeled midsole, quick-dry mesh
- Durability
- High, occasional lining issue
- Wet Traction
- Excellent on wet rock
The Merrell All Out Blaze is the only water shoe in this set with a genuine Vibram outsole and fully protective hiking-shoe build. Its aggressive lugs grip wet rock, river beds, and mud without slipping, while the quick-dry mesh upper and water-channeling midsole prevent sogginess after a crossing. Out-of-box comfort is a standout — no break-in needed even on long treks, and the traditional lace-up closure secures the foot better than slip-on water shoes. The mesh upper breathes well on hot days and dries quickly after a dunk, while the synthetic overlays hold up to daily wear and rugged trails.
This shoe targets hikers who need traction and foot protection on wet, rocky trails and want one shoe that pulls double duty as a travel sneaker. The premium price buys a Vibram sole and durable overlays, so budget shoppers and those who only need a casual beach slip-on should look elsewhere. A small tradeoff: after extended, heavy submersion, the inside lining may start to separate. For occasional stream crossings and rainy hikes, this is rarely an issue, and the tradeoff is worth the grip you gain.
Pros
- No break-in needed, even on long treks
- Vibram outsole grips wet rock, mud, and stream beds securely.
- Mesh upper drains fast, so shoes never stay waterlogged.
Cons
- Inside lining can detach after prolonged heavy water exposure.
A trail-capable water shoe that doesn’t compromise on grip or foot armor — well worth the investment if your hikes involve slippery rocks and stream crossings.