Best Overall
ziitop Water Shoes
Key details
- Style
- Barefoot aqua shoe
- Sizing
- Women's
- Package Weight
- 10.6 oz
- Package Dimensions
- 12.2 x 7.48 x 2.6 in
The place a water shoe fails a wide foot is the toe. The upper stops short, the toes curl, and by day two there's a hot spot where the shoe has been pressing. This is the pair in this group where that doesn't happen: the forefoot is cut wide enough that your toes lie flat, and the fit stays comfortable rather than merely not painful. That one thing is why it's our top pick, because a narrow toe box is the only flaw you can't work around after you've bought the shoe.
Underfoot it's the thin, flexible kind of sole. You feel the boat deck and the pool floor through it, which is what keeps you steady on both, and it's still enough to cross a shell beach or pick your way down to the water over rock without flinching. We came to like that more than we expected on wet surfaces. They dry overnight, and the listed package weight is 10.58 ounces, so a pair barely registers in a carry-on.
Ordering takes a minute of attention. The listing files these under women's sizing even though the title reads men's and women's, and the unhappy buyers are usually men who clicked their usual number. Check which scale the size you're choosing belongs to, and if you're buying for a man's foot, work from the conversion rather than from the size on his running shoes.
What they aren't is a hiking shoe. On a long rocky portage or a trail that turns into a scramble, you'll want the firmer sole and the toe bumper of something like the KEEN below. These are for the walk to the water, the swim, the boat, the pool deck, and the campground shower — a narrower job than some shoes here take on, and the one most beach trips actually need.
Pros
- Roomy toe box for a broad forefoot
- Protects on shells and rough rock
- Dries fast and packs flat
Cons
- Life span is short at this price
If your forefoot is the reason water shoes never fit, start here: these have the roomiest toes in the group and are the cheapest way to find out whether a barefoot-style shoe suits you.