Camco Portable Toilet Bucket Best Overall
Key details
- Weight
- 4.7 lb
- Height
- 16.1 inches
- Capacity
- 5 gallons
- Waste Handling
- Bag liners
Every flush toilet on this list seals waste with a valve, and a valve is the part that lets you down at eleven at night. The Camco bucket has no valve, no pump, and no water. It's a five-gallon pail with a seat and lid that snap over the rim, a molded handle, and a smooth interior that wipes clean in one pass. That's why it takes the top slot: for most campers, a toilet that cannot malfunction is worth more than one with more features.
At 4.7 pounds it's the lightest thing here, and it stands 16.1 inches tall, which puts the seat at roughly chair height — no squatting, no bracing against a tree. We carried it one-handed from the truck to the far side of a site without thinking about it, and it stayed put on ground that was nowhere near level. The lid snaps on hard enough that you need a firm pull to get it off, which is good for odor and mildly annoying at night.
What you give up is the flush. Every visit means a fresh liner, and the liner leaves with you, so a supply of heavy bags and a scoop of absorbent gel are part of the purchase. The pail also earns its keep between trips as a gear bin and a step stool, and the seat stays attached when you pick it up by the handle. If you want a bowl of water and a push button, that's a different product on this list and a much bigger line on the receipt.
Pros
- Nothing to leak, flush, or repair
- Lightest toilet here at 4.7 pounds
- Smooth interior wipes clean fast
- Seat and lid snap on tight
Cons
- Every use means a bag you carry out
Buy this one unless you specifically want a flush: it's the least expensive, lightest, most forgiving toilet here, and the only one with nothing to break.