Best Overall
Merrell Moab 3
Key details
- Fit
- Roomy toe box
- Style
- Low hiking shoe
- Department
- Men's
Most backpacking shoes ask you to choose sides: a stiff boot that braces your ankle and punishes the first few miles, or a light shoe that feels wonderful until the trail turns to rock. The Moab 3 lands in the middle, and the middle is where most trips actually live. It's a low-cut shoe, so it won't lock an ankle down the way the Columbia Newton Ridge does, but it also doesn't need a week of breaking in before it stops hurting.
The fit is what we noticed first. The toe box runs roomy enough that your feet can spread under a load, and the heel still stays put once the laces are cinched — the combination that keeps blisters off a long descent. Half sizes help here, and the shoe is soft enough out of the box that a short walk is a realistic first outing rather than a formality.
Traction is the other thing we kept coming back to. The lug pattern bites on wet rock and rooted trail and doesn't pack up with mud, which matters far more than cushioning on the day a shower catches you on an exposed ridge. Underfoot there's enough structure that a loaded pack doesn't fold your foot over every rock edge, and not so much that the shoe fights you on smooth trail.
So this is the pair we point most backpackers to. It sits mid-pack on price, near the top of this group on comfort, and it's the most forgiving shoe here if you're moving from day hikes into overnights and don't want to think hard about footwear. If your trips are consistently wet, cold, and rocky, the leather boots below are worth the trade; for everything else, start here.
Pros
- Roomy toe box with a locked-in heel
- Comfortable straight out of the box
- Tread grips wet rock and roots
- Half sizes make fitting easier
Cons
- Toe bumper and sole edge can peel with hard use
Buy it if you want one shoe for mixed-terrain backpacking with a light-to-moderate pack; we've found nothing here that balances comfort, grip, and price as well.