Best Overall
Orolay Thickened Down Jacket
Key details
- Type
- Down puffer
- Pockets
- Zipped, plus side hem zips
- Shipping Weight
- 2.73 lb
It's a light jacket that behaves like a heavy one, and that's most of the reason the Orolay is the first one we recommend. The down warms up fast, the fleece-lined hood is the part you notice on a 7 a.m. walk, and the body is cut generously enough to close over a sweater without making you look like a sleeping bag. For one coat that has to handle a city winter, a trip, and a dinner reservation, this is the safest money in the group.
The details keep us coming back to it. The hand pockets are zipped and set high, which keeps them clear of a crossbody strap even if it puts them at an odd angle for cold hands, and the side zips at the hem open the coat up when you're climbing into a car or adding a chunky knit underneath. There are more zippers here than the design strictly needs, but the useful ones are the ones you'll actually touch.
Fit is the thing to plan for. It runs small, so if you want a sweater underneath, order up rather than hoping the side zips buy you the room — they widen the hem, not the shoulders. Get the size right and it's a coat that disappears into a trip: warm enough for real winter, tidy enough for dinner, and easy to fold onto the back seat of a car.
Pros
- Warm down fill without much weight
- Generous cut layers over a sweater
- Fleece-lined hood and zipped pockets
- Side hem zips add room to move
Cons
- Main zip can stick and grab fabric
We recommend the Orolay as the default winter coat for most women: warm, roomy, good-looking enough for work, and easy to travel with.