Best Overall
BAGSMART Weekender Duffel
Key details
- Weight
- 0.88 lb
- Capacity
- 37 liters
- Dimensions
- 18.5 x 8.7 x 14.2 inches
- Shoe Compartment
- Bottom zip section
Under a pound is the number that decided this one. At 0.88 pounds empty, the BAGSMART is the lightest bag here that lists a weight, and every ounce of that is an ounce you get to spend on clothes instead. It is also shaped for the personal-item end of the cabin rather than the overhead bin: 18.5 by 8.7 by 14.2 inches and 37 liters, soft enough to squeeze into the gap under the seat in front of you. For a two- or three-night trip with one bag, that combination is the most useful thing in this guide.
The shoe compartment runs along the bottom, which is the arrangement we prefer at this size. Shoes lie flat against the base in their own zipped section and the clothes above them stay clean. A slim toiletry bag comes in the box at 9.4 by 1.6 by 5.5 inches, thin enough for an exterior pocket, though you will still want your own bottles for anything bigger than travel size. The outer zip pocket takes a passport and a phone, and the side pockets hold a water bottle or a compact umbrella.
What you give up is structure. This is a soft nylon duffel with no frame, so it slumps into a puddle when it is half packed and only holds a crisp shape when it is full. We do not mind the trade, since a bag that collapses is a bag that fits under a seat, but if you want something that stands up in a hotel lobby, the canvas pick below is the better answer. Pack it full, keep the shoes in their own section, and it does everything a weekend asks.
Pros
- 37 liters in a personal-item footprint
- 0.88 pounds empty
- Bottom shoe compartment keeps clothes clean
- Slim toiletry bag included
Cons
- Soft shell collapses when part-packed
For a two- or three-night flight with one bag, this is the one we reach for: 37 liters in a personal-item footprint, a real shoe compartment, and under a pound empty.