Best Overall
Columbia Crestwood Waterproof
Key details
- Model
- Crestwood
- Style
- Low-cut hiking shoe
- Waterproofing
- Waterproof
The trip we had in mind when we put this guide together was a week of walking somewhere it rains: wet cobblestones, a muddy path out to a viewpoint, and one pair of shoes that also works at dinner. The Crestwood is the closest thing here to covering all three. Feet stay dry through showers and creek crossings, there is no break-in to plan around, and the low profile reads as a sneaker rather than a trail shoe. It is the pair we recommend without a list of conditions attached.
Underfoot it is a hiking shoe in a sneaker's body. There is enough structure for gravel and packed dirt, and enough flex that a long pavement day does not leave your arches aching. The flex is also the boundary: on genuinely rocky ground the sole gives more than a dedicated hiker's. If your trip is mostly scree and boulders, the Merrell Moab 3 or the KEEN Targhee is the better call. For a week that is four-fifths city, we take the lighter shoe every time.
Grip is the part we have come to trust. It is a low-cut shoe with a fairly modest lug, yet wet gravel and slick pavement do not trouble it, and the tread does not pack up with mud the way some deeper soles do. On smooth wet stone the heel holds, which is rarer at this weight than it should be.
Sizing is the one thing to get right. This shoe runs a touch small for a fair number of feet, so if you are between sizes or plan to wear thicker socks on the plane, go up a half. Order early enough to walk a mile in them before you pack. Beyond that, this is the pair that asks the least of you: no break-in, no second shoe in the bag, no checking the forecast twice.
Pros
- Keeps feet dry in rain and creek crossings
- Comfortable from the first wear
- Grips wet gravel and slick pavement
- Low-cut profile that passes in town
Cons
- Sole flexes more than a dedicated hiker on rock
Our pick for most trips: dry feet in rain, no break-in, and a low profile that works in town as well as on an easy trail.