Best Overall
Columbia Peakfreak II Outdry
Key details
- Cut
- Low-cut trail shoe
- Model
- 2005101
- Waterproofing
- Outdry
Weight is the first thing that registers. Next to the leather pairs here, the Peakfreak II feels closer to a running shoe than a hiking shoe, and that's the quality we kept coming back to across long days — airport corridors in the morning, wet cobblestones in the afternoon, a trail the next day. The Outdry construction keeps water out without the sealed-in, clammy feel of a heavily padded waterproof shoe.
Grip is the other half of it. The outsole holds on wet pavement and on slick, muddy slopes, which is the combination a travel shoe actually meets; a shoe that only grips rock is no use on a rainy sidewalk. Underfoot it's soft without feeling vague, and the toe box leaves room for feet that swell on a long flight. When there's room for one pair, this is the one we take.
Fit is the easy part: they come up close to true, so if you're between sizes and wearing thick socks, take the larger one. From there the shoe asks nothing of you — no break-in period, no special socks, no planning around it. That's the argument for choosing it over the cheaper pairs here, which ask you to compromise on weight or on how consistently they fit.
Pros
- Light enough to forget you're wearing them
- Keeps water out without feeling clammy
- Grips wet pavement and muddy slopes
- Soft underfoot from the first wear
Cons
- Sole bond and tongue can give out early
Our pick for most trips: light, genuinely waterproof, and grippy on wet streets and easy trails.