Best Overall
KEEN Newport H2
Key details
- Style
- Water sandal
- Toe Style
- Closed toe
- Department
- Women's
- Package Weight
- 1.87 lb
The Newport H2 is the closest thing here to a hiking shoe that happens to drain. The rubber toe bumper wraps the front, the upper is cut like a sandal, and the straps hold the foot over a molded footbed. That combination is why it earns the top slot: on a trail that alternates dry rock and shallow creek, you don't have to change shoes or worry about a toe stub.
We paid close attention to the fit because this is where the Newport can go wrong. It runs small and narrow for some women, and the heel strap takes a tug to get over the foot. Sizing up half a size is the safer call if you're between sizes or wear a thicker sock; once it's on, the arch support and secure straps are what make it feel like a hiking sandal rather than a pool shoe.
Traction is the other reason it stays at the top. The sole is designed for wet, uneven ground, and the closed toe gives you a buffer when the trail turns to roots and loose rock. We also like that the footbed is supportive enough for the walk in and out, not just the crossing. It carries more shoe than an open sandal, and it doesn't dry as quickly as a stripped-down water shoe, but that is the trade for protection.
If your hikes are mostly smooth creek beds and you want maximum airflow, the Whisper is the less covered choice. If you have a wide forefoot and the Newport pinches, the Dannto is the roomier closed-toe alternative. For mixed rock, roots, and water, though, the Newport is the pair we recommend first.
Pros
- Closed toe protects against rocks and roots
- Secure sandal fit with real arch support
- Grippy sole for wet, uneven ground
- Durable enough for repeat wet hikes
Cons
- Premium price
We recommend the Newport H2 first for women who want one pair for rocky, wet trails: a protected toe, secure sandal fit, and real arch support, provided you size for a roomier fit.