Best Overall
Boogie Insect Repellent Lotion
Key details
- Form
- 6 fl oz lotion
- Active Ingredient
- 20% picaridin
- No-see-um Protection
- Up to 8 hours
- Mosquito And Tick Protection
- Up to 14 hours
Half the repellents we packed for this guide promise mosquitoes and ticks and leave midges to your imagination. Boogie is the one that writes no-see-ums into its own directions: up to 8 hours against flies, gnats, chiggers and no-see-ums, and up to 14 hours against mosquitoes and ticks, from 20% picaridin. When the thing you're buying is protection from insects you can barely see, that specificity is the reason it sits at the top of this list.
The format settles the rest. A lotion goes exactly where midges land — ankles, wrists, the back of the neck, the hairline — with no mist cloud in a tent and nothing lost to a breeze. We passed it around a picnic table and nobody objected to the smell, which is half the battle: the formula is fragrance-free and dries down without the greasy film that makes people skip a second application. It's also the bottle we're comfortable putting on a squirmy kid, since there's no propellant and no cloud to breathe.
Boogie is the newer of the two picaridin lotions here, and the one with less history behind it. If that gives you pause on a trip where one bad dusk means a week of itching, Sawyer is the safer feeling buy. A label that tells you exactly what it does about midges is still worth the leap.
Pros
- 20% picaridin in a fragrance-free lotion
- Names no-see-ums with an 8-hour window
- Precise on ankles, hairline and face
- No propellant cloud around kids
Cons
- Midges get 8 hours, not the 14-hour mosquito figure
- Slower head-to-toe than an aerosol
The bottle we hand anyone heading somewhere buggy: odorless 20% picaridin lotion that names no-see-ums on the label, with up to eight hours.