Best Overall
SANTINY Hiking Cargo Shorts
Key details
- Inseam
- 5, 7, or 9 in.
- Pockets
- 4 zip pockets
- Department
- Women's
Three inseams under one product page is what puts this pair first. SANTINY sells the same short in 5, 7, and 9 inches, and for thick thighs that choice does more than any fabric claim: the 9-inch puts cloth between the thighs where they meet, the 7-inch is the warm-weather all-rounder, and the 5-inch is for hikers whose legs clear each other. Three genuinely different shorts, one listing.
The cut backs it up. There's room through the leg without a sack-like swing, the fabric is thin and light, and the shorts hold their place on a climb instead of creeping up the inner thigh — the small failure that turns a mild rub into a raw patch by afternoon. Four zip pockets, mesh-lined so grit falls through, take a phone and a key without dragging the waistband down, and the pair dries fast enough to rinse at a hostel sink and wear the next morning.
Sizing is where it gets fiddly. These run large, and the waist is the part that gets noticed: a band that feels snug on an otherwise roomy short comes up again and again, and a few hikers find the leg a full size bigger than expected. If you're between sizes, take the smaller one and try the waist before the tags come off.
For a first pair, we point to the 9-inch in a dark color. It covers the stretch of trail where chafing starts, it looks tidy enough for dinner in town, and if the 9 turns out to be more coverage than you want, you know exactly which length to order next.
Pros
- Three inseam lengths in one listing
- Stays put instead of riding up the inner thigh
- Four mesh-lined zip pockets
- Dries fast enough to sink-wash
Cons
No notable drawbacks to flag.
Our top pick: three inseam lengths in one listing mean you can buy the coverage your thighs actually need, and the cut stays put on a climb.